The magician displays a large jar of Peanut Butter on one side of the stage (or living room) and a jar of Jelly on the other side. He covers both jars, and after the magic words, he explains that the Peanut Butter and Jelly have changed places! The kids are skeptical, but they're ready to believe. Before he lifts the covers to verify his claim, he offers to repeat the , miracle "magically" returning the jars to where they first started. The kids are even less convinced than before, in fact they're ready to boo him off the stage. Negotiating for one last chance to prove himself, a child from the audience is invited up to examine two pieces of real bread, which are placed into an ordinary brown paper bag. The child is asked to hold the bag and stand precisely between the two jars. This time, at the magician's command, the Peanut Butter and Jelly change places! He lifts the covers and shows that the change has happened! As further proof of the invisible flight across the stage, the Peanut Butter and Jelly left some evidence behind! The child reaches into the bag to remove the bread and instead finds a complete Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich, which is his or hers to keep!
Please Note: This trick now is supplied with "Fake" Peter Pan style Peanut Butter Jars called "Peter Pen", however the Tubes supplied are solid Black and Heavy Duty Rubber.